Margarita Pizzeria & Restaurant

Reviews

• Melinda K.

  star star star star star 24 September 2026

  First time ordering take out--
  
  Plenty of seating with a very causal atmosphere. Order from printed paper menu at the counter. Typical pizzeria setup.
  
  Followed a previous yelp review suggestion and went with the Special cheesesteak. Ordered the 16"  cheese,
  mushrooms, peppers and onion, cheesesteak. I was not disappointed by any means! Portion size was perfect to split between two (along with an appetizer). Very generous filling portions. Perfect ratio of all toppings with amount of bread. I would highly recommend.
  
  Tried the fried calamari. Very flavorful. We were a bit bummed that it was not crispier. To be fair, it was take out and the steam from the container probably didn't help keep the crisp. Maybe poking a few holes may help avoid the steam buildup causing the fried calamari from becoming more on the soggy side.
  
  The gentleman that took our order was friendly despite being the only one manning the counter and what appears to be making the pizza.  
  
  Overall, I would return for an in-the-bind kind of day for reasonably priced Italian take out.

• Danielle Z.

  star star star star_border star_border 12 September 2026

  Decided to try a new pizza place for once. I ordered through doordash. Asked for ranch on the side got Italian dressing instead, not sure if that is the pizzerias fault or doordash.
  
  I ordered a large cheese pizza, calamari, and a small garden salad.
  
  The pros- The pizza was not very greasy and had a decent amount of cheese on it. The sauce was okay, nothing special.  The price was average. The salad is a nice size for a small, typical romaine lettuce, shredded carrots, black olives, tomatoes, and cucumbers. It came with two pieces of bread, which was standard italian bread, it was stale and tasted sour.
  
  Cons- The pizza was sloppy looking and the cheese looked swirled. The taste was just okay, looked slightly undercooked.
  
  The calamari was completely tasteless and came with only a small amount of tomato sauce. The lemon was not even cut into nice wedges but they did give a half a lemon. Some of the pieces were rubbery and some were tender. Completely inconsistent. Honestly it was hard to even eat half of the small amount they give you. It was awful.
  
  The salad was pretty much all romaine, there were only two pieces of cucumber and two small quarted pieces of tomato,  both weren't very ripe. Everything basically except the romain lettuce was skimpy. Considering it is nearly 5$ it is not a
  good buy. The dressing was also in a tiny container. [Wasn't the right one but I decided to try it, was mostly oil.]
  
  Overall not a good first impression of this place. I would not order from this place again or recommend it at all.

• Stephane M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 7 September 2026

  Place is extremely dirty. I went in at 8pm. I'm not sure what are the store hours but they had nothing left beside a slice of pepperoni and a pie of plain.  I ordered a pepperoni thinking they were going to heat it up, no they grab  a slice of plain and added a pepperoni pieces to it that has been sitting in a bucket God knows for how long. Register is filthy dirty doesn't even want to make you order from there because we all know pizzeria does everything without gloves. Won't be returning.

• Sofia P.

  star star star star star 5 September 2026

  Italian pizza with sausage pepper onion and potatoes are the best. Seriously have cravings for it after trying it at friends place. Cheesesteak is also meaty and I love the bread they use. Will try more menus in the future! Recommend italian pizza

• Michelle L.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 30 August 2026

  My husband and I stopped here for a quick bite. The place is old and run down looking and the pizza looked like it was sitting there for days. We were hungry and rushing so we got 2 slices to go anyway. I got a piece of sicilian and my husband got plain. He hated his slice. Mine was okay but not great. We won't be back or recommend. Sorry!